Back to blog

LinkedIn Ads6 min read

8 reasons why most LinkedIn campaigns fail before they even start

Most LinkedIn campaigns fail before they even start: the audience is too broad, the ad is about you, and every campaign is judged on one number.

A LinkedIn campaign set-up with all eight mistakes flagged before launch: the audience, the copy, the format, the number it is judged on, the leads, the demographics, the settings and the offer.

The short answer

Most LinkedIn ads fail because of decisions made before anyone opens a design file. The audience is too broad, the ad talks about the product instead of the buyer's problem, and every campaign gets judged on the same number.

New visuals won't fix any of that. When an account we take over is struggling, these are the things we change first.

The audience is too broad

LinkedIn will happily let you target ‘Directors in Finance’ and charge you to reach all of them, including people at companies that are too small, in the wrong market, or would never buy.

We build audiences from two layers: the company and the person. The company layer is a target account list wherever we can get one. The person layer is job titles or job functions.

Put them together and you get the two audiences we run most, ABM x job titles and ABM x function.

Industry x job titles is the one we avoid. Without an account list behind it, it's too broad to be worth the money.

  1. Target account list+Job titles=ABM x job titles
  2. Target account list+Job function=ABM x function
  3. Industry+Job titles=Industry x job titles

ExcludedExisting customersCompetitorsYour own staff

  • Build the account list from your closed-won deals, not a slide about your ideal customer.
  • Turn off Audience Expansion and the LinkedIn Audience Network, which push your ads beyond the list.
  • Exclude existing customers, competitors and your own staff from prospecting.

A tighter audience costs more per impression. It costs far less per meeting, and meetings are the number that matters.

The ad is about you, not the buyer

Nobody scrolls LinkedIn looking for a feature list. They're thinking about whatever went wrong at work this week. An ad that opens with the product asks them to join the dots themselves, and most won't bother.

So we open with a problem and give the solution in the next sentence. Before we write a single ad, we write the client's story: the problems their customers have, what happens if they do nothing, what's blocking them, the proof and the product. Every ad comes out of that.

First, the story

  • Their problems
  • What happens if they do nothing
  • What's blocking them
  • The proof
  • The product
  1. Job 1

    Problem ad

    Hits the pain they feel today.

  2. Job 2

    Product ad

    Shows how the product solves it.

  3. Job 3

    Conversion ad

    Gives a reason to act now.

    Book

All three in one ad does none of them well.

Open with a problem, then provide a solution in the next sentence.

Each ad also gets one job. A problem ad hits the pain they feel today, a product ad shows how the product solves it and a conversion ad gives a reason to act now.

Cram all three into one ad and it does none of them well.

Using the wrong format for the wrong objective

LinkedIn gives you image ads, video, documents, thought leader ads and conversation ads. Plenty of accounts pick one and run it for everything, then wonder why the video campaign never books a meeting. Each format is built for a different objective.

  1. Image ads
    • Awareness
    • Engagement
    • Traffic
  2. Video
    • Video views
  3. Document ads
    • Downloads
  4. Thought leader ads
    • Engagement to retarget
  5. Conversation ads
    • High-intent conversions

Match the format to the objective, then judge it on that objective. Which is the next mistake.

Judging everything on cost per lead

Judge an awareness campaign on cost per lead and it will always look like a failure. Someone switches it off, and a few months later the demo campaigns run dry because nobody knows who you are.

We split budgets into groups and give each group its own number. Awareness is judged on click-through rate, thought leader ads on engagement rate and demos on cost per lead.

The best ads in each group get more budget. The worst go on what we call the naughty list and get paused.

Tracking an image ad all the way to pipeline is hard. Most of the people it reached never clicked, so your CRM can't see them. Tools such as Fibbler match the companies your ads were shown to against the deals you closed, so you can see the overall impact the ads had on closing deals, even when nobody filled in a form.

  1. AwarenessClick-through rateCTR

  2. Thought leader adsEngagement rateER

  3. DemosCost per leadCPL

Best ads get more budgetWorst go on the naughty list and get paused

Nobody looks at the leads

The next mistake is never checking who actually came through. Every week we mark each lead as good, unsure or bad, and we ask the client to do the same.

The bad ones tell you what to exclude: job titles that never turn into pipeline, and companies you don't want to pay for again. The good ones you track down the funnel, to see which ones turn into meetings, opportunities and closed deals.

This week’s leads10 leads

  • VP MarketingTarget accountGood
  • StudentUniversityBad
  • Head of Demand GenTarget accountGood
  • Marketing ManagerMid-marketUnsure
  • Founder4 staffBad
  • CMOTarget accountGood
  • Account ManagerAgencyBad
  • Growth LeadUnknownUnsure
  • Marketing DirectorTarget accountGood
  • Sales RepCompetitorBad

BadBecome exclusions

  • Students
  • Agencies
  • Under 50 staff
  • Competitors

GoodTracked down the funnel

  1. Lead4
  2. Meeting3
  3. Opportunity2
  4. Closed1

Then you adjust the targeting to match who's coming through. More of the audiences that produce good leads, less of the ones that don't.

Nobody looks at the demographics report

Every campaign in LinkedIn has a demographics report. It breaks down who has actually seen your ads: industries, company sizes, job titles, seniority, companies and more. Most accounts never open it.

It's the quickest way to find out whether the spend went where the targeting said it would. If a campaign aimed at Directors is mostly reaching Managers, or half the impressions went to companies with ten staff, you fix the targeting, not the creative.

You can take the same look at any audience you've saved and see its makeup before it goes live. So check it before a campaign launches, and keep checking it. This is something to optimise against continually, not once.

DemographicsWho saw the ads

  1. Marketing Manager34%
  2. Marketing Director22%
  3. Head of Marketing17%
  4. Marketing Executive15%
  5. CMO12%

Not who the campaign was aimed at

  1. Before it goes live

    Open the saved audience and check its makeup.

  2. Every week after

    Read the report and tighten the targeting against it.

Having the stupid settings turned on

LinkedIn turns a few settings on by default that help LinkedIn more than they help you. Each one wastes money in its own way.

  1. Audience expansion

    Adds people LinkedIn thinks look like your audience. Your budget goes to companies off your list.

  2. LinkedIn Audience Network

    Puts your ads on third-party apps and sites. LinkedIn prices, cheap placements, worse clicks.

  3. Maximum delivery

    Hands your bids to LinkedIn. It spends the full budget at whatever CPM it likes.

Always turn them off

  • Audience expansion adds people LinkedIn thinks look like your audience. They aren't on your account list, so your budget goes to companies you'd never sell to.
  • The LinkedIn Audience Network shows your ads on third-party apps and sites. You pay LinkedIn prices for cheap placements, with the worst engagement and clicks from people who never saw a feed.
  • Maximum delivery hands your bids to LinkedIn, which spends the full budget at whatever CPM it likes. A manual bid, set low and raised slowly, usually buys the same reach for less.

Turn all three off in every campaign, every time.

Not saying anything meaningful enough to get a conversion

‘Book a demo’ is not an offer. It asks a stranger to give up half an hour with a salesperson and get nothing certain in return. Most people won't, however good the ad.

A conversion happens when the value is obvious and the risk is low. So every conversion ad needs an offer that does both: give them something, and make saying yes easy. Incentives work, and these are the ones that work best.

Half an hour with sales, nothing certain back

Value to them
15%
Risk for them
85%

Something useful, little effort on their side

Value to them
90%
Risk for them
10%

Raise the value, lower the risk

  • Free trials, so they can use the product before they talk to anyone.
  • Product offers: a discount, extra seats or a longer term for signing now.
  • Zero-risk guarantees, so the risk sits with you rather than them.
  • A free consultation, audit or analysis that takes little effort on their side. You do the work, they get something useful whether they buy or not.

Whatever you pick, say in the ad why they should take it. Give them a reason, not just a button.

Key takeaway

The takeaway

Fix the audience, open with the problem, match the format to the objective and judge each budget group on its own number. Check who's actually coming through, turn the default settings off and give people a real reason to convert. Then the creative finally gets a fair chance to work.

In this article
  1. The short answer
  2. The audience is too broad
  3. The ad is about you, not the buyer
  4. Using the wrong format for the wrong objective
  5. Judging everything on cost per lead
  6. Nobody looks at the leads
  7. Nobody looks at the demographics report
  8. Having the stupid settings turned on
  9. Not saying anything meaningful enough to get a conversion
  10. The takeaway
Share this post
  • Drive More Meetings
  • Increase Pipeline
  • Strategies That Work

We run LinkedIn and Google Ads for B2B brands, and we’re good at it.

Get the libraryBook a Call

More articles

Back to blog

Landing Pages

How to 2x your CVR on Google with a tour

Most Google landing pages only have a Book a demo button. Add a product tour as a second way to convert and the page can double its conversion rate.

Joseph Hill5 min read

Google Ads

How to run experiments in Google Ads

Google Ads experiments are for big changes: a different landing page or a different way of optimising. Most of ours test two landing pages. Here’s when to run one and how.

Jimmy Millard4 min read